Beware the state of Nanny McUnfree
- Styli Charalambous
- 31 Jul 2010 11:34 (South Africa)
Good news: The Mother City finally had a porn conference. Bad news: It was hosted by a group called the “Justice Alliance” which is trying to block Interweb and cellphone access to the root of all evil, pornography.
The centre of this porn extravaganza will focus on filtering the content of internet service providers, presumably, to prevent sexual abuse of children. The Hugh Hefner of this conference is Peter Mancer, of Watchdog International, founded in New Zealand in 1999. Watchdog is a service providing filtering technology that integrates with ISPs, effectively censoring the content that can be viewed by various organisations and individuals.
While an admirable objective in principle, in practice enforced censorship should not be condoned as an across-the-board measure to prevent sexually deviant conduct.
The conference’s media release concludes with an example of how, according to the Justice Alliance, porn is the sole reason for the decay of our children’s moral fibre.
“Other speakers will explain the harm suffered by children as young as 10 years as a result of pornography being freely available on cellphones as well as the Internet. Recent press coverage has highlighted, for example, a group of children between the ages of 10 and 15 in Mitchell’s Plain who have filmed each other performing acts of oral sex after watching cellphone pornography.”
Admittedly this is another sad story emanating from our townships, but the question is not whether children of 10 should be exposed to pornography, but rather how the exposure should be restricted. As with all issues affecting the conduct and upbringing of children, the two bastions of “good” behaviour have always been and shall remain, education and parenting. These two elements are most likely absent from the lives of these fellating 10 year olds and no amount of Internet censorship will prevent sexually deviant conduct by these kids. Only by incorporating more education and better parenting into the lives of these kids will their behaviour be altered.
What would the Justice Alliance have done if those kids had performed the illicit acts after they had witnessed two dogs fornicating in Victoria Street? Would they be attempting to ban all canine intercourse? Of course not, that would be plain ludicrous. And equally ludicrous is the attempt to filter the porn available to all of us because some destitute, unemployed parents were too busy getting high to look after their kids.
If I want to restrict the websites my children can visit on the home computer, I’ll download Cybernanny to keep them from visiting undesirable sites, but allow adults to peruse whatever they desire. Cellphones? No problem, here you go, son, a phone that only makes calls and sends text messages. If Justice Alliance and Watchdog International have their ways, I will no longer be able to access www.crossdressingclowns.com or upload a video of the Standerton Midget Oil Wrestling Championships.
And who exactly will decide what is to be filtered (censored)? Bilbo Baggins from New Zealand, the skilfully gifted and efficient ministry of home affairs or the Justice Alliance cult? Personally, I would rather wear JZ’s soiled loin cloth on my head for a week than endure that kind of ”verkrampte” censorship.
Let’s not forget that pornography is in itself an important educational tool. Parental “birds and bees” discussions just don’t give you the level of detail necessary to know what to do and where to do it. Just like any activity watching a professional (repeatedly, even finishing before the best part) will usually up one’s game a few notches. I shudder to think how much worse off the intimate encounters of most people would be had those extramural tutorials not been consumed.
The word pornography originates from the Greek description for writing about prostitutes. And while its etymology is no longer an appropriate guide to its modern perception, the dilemma that the pornography censors face is that, like prostitution, society will not accept a scenario where it does not have access to it. Even with various technical avenues available to the draconian segements, society will always find a way to access it, albeit through illegal means. From IP address blocking to DNS filtering, the Interweb will always be one step ahead with proxy websites, VPNs and a host of other workarounds.
Censorship has now become big business alongside its socio-political implications. Many countries employ forms of censorship, ranging from a total blackout of Internet access (North Korea) to lesser nominal censorship (Australia). In response, the Parisian-based press freedom organisation, Reporters sans frontières, publishes an annual list of the “Internet enemies”.
While sites offering illegal pornographic material or extreme violence are high on the list of blacklisted sites around the world, there is defence of a principle at risk here. That principle is that moral majorities (or otherwise) should not be allowed to enforce their opinions or tastes on mentally competent adults on the basis that it is offensive or immoral. The principle is perfectly delivered through the adage, often attributed to Voltaire: "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”
Justice Alliance and their kind need to realise that the consumption of porn can sometimes merely be a symptom and not the cause of sexual misconduct. After all, porn doesn’t rape people, people rape people.
- Book review: The Grand Scam by Rob Rose – how the Tannenbaums and Madoffs get away with it
- Analysis: The Kallis Conundrum
- Read the writing on the paywall
- Balancing the budget, NDP-style
- Harnessing the power: ANC in action
- Operation Mangaung 2012: chaos reigns supreme
- Survivor: Media edition
- South Africa's bittersweet Olympics
- Ernie Els recaptures form - and the Claret jug
- The 50 Shades of Victoria's Secret
- Prohibiting prohibition
- A brief history of rogue bankers
- Boks v England: Dour end to series win
- Meyer and Boks pass first test hurdle - just
- Speartackled: The real story
- First Thing with Styli Charalambous: UN Security Council condemns Syria attack
- My coming-out story
- Dear Heyneke Meyer, April Fools' is no more
- Masters: Bubba breaks South African hearts
- Will the gays and women please rise?
- Don't touch me on my sponsor
- 25 Billion reasons why Apple isn't going away anytime soon
- The Entrepreneur Chronicles: Q&A with Ronnie Apteker
- Entrepreneur chronicles: Snapbill
- The Entrepreneur Chronicles: Dave Blakey & Snapt
- Final whistle blows for Capello
- ANC's mining solutions: a depressing exercise
- Analysis: Facebook's $100-billion reality
- Djokovic triumphs in clash of the titans
- Rugby: Letting the tiger out the bag
- The changing face of cricket
- Australian Open preview: Clash of the Titans
- 2011 - The sporting year that wasn't
- Bridging the funding divide
- Up yours! New Zealand style
- Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the best Springbok coach of all?
- What if Zuckerberg came from Sandton?
- Yippee - the Outsurance pointsmen are gone
- Six Nations is Bryce-less
- Kings of Leon: anything but a royal performance
- SA Tennis: no game, no set, no match
- Why the orchids of RWC 2011 reek of onions - An overview
- A generation later, All Blacks are World Champions again
- World Cup farce preview
- End of the Federer era? Don't bet on it
- All Blacks bundle Australia out of RWC
- Sacrebleu! as France stumble into World Cup final
- Where to now, Bokke?
- Australia break South African hearts
- Wales polish off Ireland in Wellington
- Quarterfinal crunch time at RWC
- Weekend of wonder at Rugby World Cup
- Boks bruise their way to win over Samoa
- All Blacks boss France off Auckland's Eden Park
- Bok selections: good headaches to have
- Jesus, the USA and gay rights
- Irish make mockery of the formbook and Australia
- Boks blow Fijians away in Wellington
- Boks scrape through in Wellington thriller
- The time has come: crouch, touch, pause... Engage!
- 'I got World Cup fever; she got World Cup fever!'
- Sonny Bill Williams and Rugby Union: End of a brief but dazzling affair?
- Wallabies beat All Blacks in Brisbane bruiser
- A team of 30, backed by a team of millions
- Hope restored as Boks put All Blacks to bed
- Smith's exit could be Boks' Achilles Heel
- US Open - last chance saloon for the Fed express
- John Smit drops to Bok bench for All Blacks encounter
- Moment of truth awaits the Boks in Durban
- The Global Financial Crisis - a bedtime story
- Blackout at Eden Park, as All Blacks demolish Wallabies
- Tri-Nations decider - a Pacific skirt-lifting affair
- Why I'm betting on the Boks to bring home the Rugby World Cup
- All Blacks blow Boks off Wellington's Westpac Park
- Tri-Nations preview: Winds of Wellington will blow Boks away
- Wallaby display dazzles Bok B-Team
- Tri-Nations: Short-term pain for World Cup gain
- Super Rugby fairytale Crusaders ending ruined by Red devils
- Brisbane promises breathtaking rugby as Reds face off to Crusaders
- Crusaders storm into Super 15 Final
- Serving up more economic empowerment
- LinkedIn: Taking the office Xmas party public
- Analysis: 100 billion reasons for Zuckerberg to smile
- U2 in Johannesburg - the real greatest show on earth
- Tis the season to be jolly, so hush about the church's lolly
- Beware the state of Nanny McUnfree
- Is the Internet is making us stoopid?
- Time to face reality about steroids?
- Cooler than English?
- In defence of Tiger